Paella in the Pan, on a Pedestrian Street in South Beach
The seafood paella at Españolita reaches the table in the pan it was cooked in, and the pan is crowded: lobster and king crab legs laid over the rice, with the rest of the shellfish underneath. It is the dish the camera keeps returning to, and it is also the one the restaurant puts first. Its own pitch is brief. Fresh seafood daily, a ribeye, grilled fish, and a Spanish seafood paella, all of it described as the best of land and sea. The kitchen cites more than thirty years in the business, which is a claim about experience rather than about this address, and the plate gives it a fair test.
A Street Built as Stage Set
Españolita sits at 441 Española Way, on a street that was conceived in 1925 as a Historic Spanish Village, with arched doorways, wrought-iron balconies, stucco walls and terracotta roofs. It went through decades of decline and a revival in the 1980s, and in May 2017 the city closed it to cars entirely. The restaurant works with that setting rather than against it. There is a dining room indoors, but a good part of the business is the patio and courtyard on the pedestrian street, where the tables sit in the middle of the passing traffic. A Spanish steakhouse and seafood house in a faux-Spanish village has a certain logic.
Land, Sea, and a Little Italy
The rest of the table follows the same logic as the street, which was never strictly Spanish and is now lined with Italian and French places as well. Along with the paella come ribeye and grilled fish, tapas and sangria, and the camera also catches mussels and fried calamari. Chicken parmigiana arrives with a nest of spaghetti, a dish from another country's repertoire. A slice of cheesecake with berry coulis closes the compilation. The menu reads less like a map of Spain than like a map of the block it sits on, and the paella, with its pile of shellfish, is where the kitchen's attention is most visible. Order it for the table, and leave room for the cheesecake.