A Chef's Etna Childhood, Served on Spring Street
Pane cunzato opens the menu at Piccola Cucina Osteria, and it is barely a recipe: toasted Sicilian bread dressed with olive oil and oregano, then topped with primo sale, anchovies and a purée of cherry tomatoes. The dish has nowhere to hide. The bread has to hold up under the oil, the oil has to taste of something, and the anchovy has to bring salt and depth without taking over, which is more or less the test a reviewer at Zafferano & Co set for it. A rustic plate of toast, then, placed first on the menu of a SoHo restaurant, and a fair statement of intent.
Behind it is Philip Guardione, born in Catania and raised between Sicily and Switzerland, who cooked at the Four Seasons in Milan and as a private chef in Sardinia before arriving in New York. He opened the first Piccola Cucina in SoHo in 2008, a 300-square-foot enoteca, and the Osteria followed in 2013. In August 2025 it reopened in a larger room of 900 square feet and fifty seats, next door to the old dining room, which became a wine bar called Piccola Cucina Enoteca e Bacaro. After fifteen years of menus that covered the length of Italy, Guardione said, the moment had come to cook the nonna plates of his own childhood.
The Arancino and the Pastas
The arancino Catanese is the other dish that earns the table's attention: a fried rice ball filled with meat ragù and mozzarella, which in the video filmed there arrives golden and set over a pool of sauce, two to a plate. The same video catches the tuna tartare, topped with microgreens and a small purple chip, an agreeable bit of garnish that the person holding the camera, to be fair, ranks second.
The pastas stay inside the island's repertoire: maccheroni alla Norma, with eggplant in tomato sauce and ricotta on top; a ruby-red prawn pasta built on prawns from Mazara; busiate with pistachio and squid. The Zafferano & Co review found real Sicilian ancestry in all of it and asked only that the kitchen trust that ancestry a little more.
The dish has nowhere to hide.
Sweets, Made at the Table
Dessert leans on the island too. Almond granita is made fresh daily and comes with brioche col tuppo, a pairing Guardione has argued deserves a place on American menus now that gelato no longer needs explaining. Tiramisu and cannoli are finished tableside, which in a room of fifty seats, with tables set close together, is a small piece of theater played at short range. Order the pane cunzato first, the arancino second, and let the granita have the last word.
What the critics say
Zafferano & Co found real Sicilian roots in the menu, singled out the pane cunzato as the thing to order, and said the restaurant's challenge is confidence rather than authenticity.
Cititour reported that the Osteria reopened in August 2025 in a larger 900-square-foot space steps from its original enoteca, with Guardione turning toward his Sicilian roots.
Tasting Table noted the opening of Guardione's SoHo spot with a Sicilian menu of pasta, seafood such as swordfish wrapped around buffalo mozzarella, and cassata cake.