Staten Island Thin Crust, Swirled With Pesto on Mulberry Street
The Tie Dye starts the way a margherita would, with fresh mozzarella on a thin crust, and then departs from it. Tomato sauce and vodka sauce share the surface, and a spiral of pesto goes over both. The Infatuation notes that the pesto is swirled on at the table, which turns the pie into a small piece of theater. The restaurant has trademarked the name, which says how it sees the thing. Pesto and vodka sauce both carry cheese, so the pie cannot be made vegan, a point the menu states outright.
The Hidden Food video makes the case without ever showing the sign. A chicken cutlet over spinach and mashed potatoes gets the first look, and then the thin-crust Tie Dye arrives with its green spiral, which needs no caption. On Mulberry Street the pie works as a signature in the literal sense.
A Family Recipe From Staten Island
Rubirosa opened in 2009, and its pizza has a lineage. Giuseppe Pappalardo founded Joe & Pat's, a Staten Island institution, and his son AJ opened Rubirosa to build one of his own in Manhattan, starting from the family's pizza recipe. The Classic, tomato sauce and mozzarella, is still listed as the Pappalardo recipe established in 1960. AJ kept his father's technique and added newer sauces and toppings, the vodka pie among them.
Time Out described the result as crisp yet pliable, with a delicate char and a small ring of crackerlike crust at the edge. The same review used a useful shorthand for the style: Staten Island pies, which is to say thin crust with vodka sauce. Rubirosa's version has the vodka sauce on the pizza and, as of the Tie Dye, the pesto on top of it.
The restaurant has trademarked the name, which says how it sees the thing.
The Pasta Is the Argument
The Infatuation's review makes the case that the Tie Dye is only the beginning, and that the other food is as good as the pizza or better. It singles out a velvety carbonara and cavatelli with red pepper flake, broccoli rabe and big knobs of sausage. Lumache alla Vodka carries the pizza's signature sauce onto handmade pasta, and a Black & White Tagliatelle of squid ink pasta, shrimp, cockles and calamari moves toward the sea. A full gluten-free pizza list mirrors the main one, Tie Dye included.
A Hard Table in Nolita
The room sits on Mulberry Street between Prince and Spring, in the part of Nolita that used to be called Little Italy, and it fills accordingly. Reservations are released a week out and go quickly, though walk-ins are accepted, and the host may send them off for a couple of hours. The restaurant now sells its own jarred sauces, a mark of how far the family recipe has traveled from Staten Island. Order the Tie Dye for the spiral, then keep the table for the carbonara.
What the critics say
The Infatuation called Rubirosa a Nolita institution and argued that the pasta, such as the carbonara and the cavatelli with sausage and broccoli rabe, deserves as much attention as the Tie Dye pizza.
Time Out described the pies as crisp yet pliable, with a delicate char and a thin ring of crackerlike crust around the edge.
Time Out gave the restaurant four stars and named the Tie Dye its most famous pie, a margherita variation with vodka sauce and pesto swirled on top in place of basil.