The Roasted Oyster Comes First, in the Old Etta's Room
The roasted oyster at Half Shell comes out alone. One oyster, dressed with 'nduja butter and breadcrumbs and finished with grilled lemon, sits in a small white dish, and in the footage a glass of champagne stands behind it. The 'nduja is a spreadable, spiced pork sausage, so the butter arrives already carrying fat and chili, and the breadcrumbs give the top a crust where the rest is soft. The grilled lemon is the acid that keeps the whole thing from tipping over. It is a single bite served as a prologue, which is a more disciplined way to begin a dinner than most.
The cold course follows on a metal tray: raw oysters on crushed ice, the shell liquor still pooled in each one, with sauce and another lemon wedge for squeezing. The kitchen sends them with a tabasco mignonette and a sleeve of Ritz crackers, and the daily selection changes with what is on hand. The Seattle Times, reviewing the place, was served Fanny Bay oysters that were "cool and sea-sweet with that cucumber-y finish," which is the Pacific Northwest style the menu is built around.
A Douglas Family Room
Half Shell opened in May 2024 at the north end of Pike Place Market, in the space that had been Etta's, next door to the company's more casual Seatown. It belongs to Tom Douglas & Co., and the lineage is part of the premise: Douglas found his first restaurant job shucking oysters in Delaware, and he is sometimes found at Half Shell doing the same. The concept and design came from his daughter Loretta Douglas, working with company director Amy Richardson. The result is an oyster bar with a martini list attached, which in a building with this much water outside its windows seems the right way round.
It is a single bite served as a prologue, which is a more disciplined way to begin a dinner than most.
Crab Roll, Burger, Fries
That same review spent as much time away from the shell as on it. The Dungeness crab roll, with gently butter-poached meat under a feather-light charred-lemon aioli on a Macrina roll, was judged far better than the chain lobster rolls around town. The surprise was the hamburger: house-ground Painted Hills chuck, American cheese, tartar sauce and a sesame bun, which the critic found basic in the most beautiful way. The twice-fried fries drew praise of their own. For something heavier there is steak frites with a foraged porcini mushroom jus, a plate that keeps the seafood house honest about its second language.
Martinis at the Pearl Bar
The Pearl Bar is where the room's second subject lives, in icy martinis, bubbles and spritzes. The Half Shell Martini is Beefeater gin with amontillado sherry infused with oyster shell, a drink that makes the same argument as the menu in liquid form, and the Dirty Shucker takes vodka, pickle juice and dill vermouth. The room has booths, sea-inspired decor and large windows toward Puget Sound. Seattle Met, in its roundup of the city's seafood, called Half Shell a modern update to the classic oyster bar and said it is better than it needs to be, especially at happy hour, when a mini-tini washes down a roasted oyster. Order the roasted oyster first, as the room intends, and let the cold tray come after it.
What the critics say
The Seattle Times praised the Dungeness crab roll, the Painted Hills hamburger and the twice-fried fries, and noted that Tom Douglas began his restaurant career shucking oysters in Delaware.
Seattle Met included Half Shell in its guide to the best seafood in Seattle, singling out the happy hour roasted oyster with 'nduja butter and the ginger shrimp nugget slider.
The Seattle Times profiled Loretta Douglas and credited Half Shell, an oyster bar in the old Etta's space, with helping her make her mark in the family company.