The Chowder That Beat New England at Its Own Contest
In 2000, Larry Mellum entered a clam chowder in the Great Chowder Cook-Off in Newport, Rhode Island, a contest that in twenty years had never gone to a restaurant from outside New England. It took first place, then took it again in each of the next two years. That earned the chowder a spot in the cook-off's Hall of Fame and, under the rules, a ten-year absence from the clam division. Mellum had been making seafood chowder in the Pacific Northwest since 1991. After Newport, he has said, his first thought was that he wanted to be at Pike Place Market, and in 2003 he opened a counter there. The order matters: the recipe came first and the address second.
A Bowl Built on Bacon
The New England clam is the bowl behind the trophies. It is made with meaty clams, bacon, cream and a blend of herbs and spices the kitchen keeps to itself. The chowder is cooked from scratch in small batches, with the work starting at 2 a.m., and the vegetables come straight from the Market's stalls. When it went back to Newport after its decade on the bench, The Seattle Times reported, it came home with second place in the clam division, behind a New Jersey restaurant. It has since collected seventeen first-place titles in cook-offs from Rhode Island and Connecticut to Oregon and California.
Eight chowders are on the board, and the clam is only the first. There is a seafood bisque, a seared scallop chowder and a crab and oyster. There is also a vegan chowder of lime and coconut, which the restaurant's own news page calls an unsung hero. The range is the second argument the place makes, after the trophies.
The order matters: the recipe came first and the address second.
The Sampler and the Roll
Choosing is the main difficulty here, and the restaurant solves it with a sampler of four small cups. That is what the Hidden Food video shows: a tray of assorted hot chowders beside a lobster roll, and a spoon stirring the thick clam chowder in close-up. The roll comes with Maine lobster, Dungeness crab or shrimp, built on brioche from Grand Central Bakery. The Infatuation weighed the tourist-trap question and concluded that the clam chowder was good anyway. Its critic advised standing in line, and also staying away from the smoked salmon chowder, which was heavy on cream cheese. That is an honest note on a menu where the clam is the point.
Twenty Seats, One Alley
The first Pike Place Chowder held about twenty seats, and the flagship on brick-paved Post Alley is still small. The line is part of the experience, the restaurant says, and it moves fast. The business grew out of a small West Seattle kitchen where Mellum and head chef Mike Hillyer spent their days cooking and tinkering. The Hillyer family, which now runs it, has kept it family-owned. A second restaurant opened at Pacific Place in 2007 with a longer menu, which leaves the Market counter free to do the one thing it is known for. Order the clam first, and let the rest of the tray argue its case afterward.
What the critics say
The Infatuation said the clam chowder is good enough to justify the line, and advised ordering it over the smoked salmon chowder, which it found heavy on cream cheese.
The Seattle Times reported that the chowder took second place for best clam chowder at Rhode Island's Great Chowder Cook-Off, plus first place for the most spirited team.
Eater Seattle included Pike Place Chowder in a 2021 list of places to get comforting soups and stews for wintry Seattle weather.